Collectively deciding between alternatives08 Dec 2008
The November issue of msdn magazine has a nice piece by Dr. James McCaffrey on determining a best option from a list of choices. It’s an interesting departure from his usual topic, testing, and it proposes a discussion and implementation of the Schultze method. As far as I remember, Arrow’s impossibility theorem demonstrates that
no voting system can convert the ranked preferences of individuals into a community-wide ranking while also meeting a certain set of reasonable criteria with three or more discrete options to choose from.
Therefore, I have to assume that there are limitations to this method. If I have time, I’ll try to figure out in what cases these show up. However, the exposition of the problem is worth reading.
Have a comment or a question? Ping me on Twitter, or use the comments section!